When Author, Artist Lives Get Messy, Should Stores Pull Product?
As someone who has spent time leading worship in several different churches, I still get excited when I hear a new song. If the song really captures me — as one did recently — I’ll tell everyone I meet about it.
About a month ago I found such a song. It was a beautiful worship song that also contained teaching and exhortation — the best of all possible worlds worlds — and reminded me of some classic Andrae Crouch, or at least what he might write in 2015.
And then everything crashed. I was telling a group of people about it and they proceeded to tell me a whole load of details about the artist, his affair, his marriage breakup and more. Hours later I went online only to discover everything they said was true, not that I should have doubted.
While I should have grieved over the artist’s sin (and my own), at that point my thoughts were entirely selfish. “Darn;” I thought; “I liked that song.”
Two weeks later I decided to play the song on YouTube one more time. Then my wife and I had a discussion about whether or not the song is in any way invalidated by the fact that the writer, like all of us, is flawed.
On Sunday night the discussion came up again in reference to an author. (See yesterday’s blog post.) Should Christian bookstores simply pull his product off the shelves? If they do so, should this be permanent or just for a season? Is the truth contained in those books in any way invalidated by more recent events?
Christian booksellers went through this when Amy Grant and Sandi Patti each were divorced. When Jennifer Knapp and Ray Boltz came out as gay. More recently, when Mark Driscoll admitted he plagiarized large sections of his books.
Of course, sometimes, the truth just isn’t there. The boy in The Boy Who Came Back From Heaven now admits he was never there in the first place. That’s a different type of situation. But last time I checked, those classic Amy and Sandi albums are back on the shelves, and this time around, some stores didn’t bother pulling Driscoll product at all.
I really like the song with which I began this discussion. I don’t wanna go all Charismatic on you and say it’s anointed, but it’s certainly special, at least to me. Does it not remain valid despite all the back-story? Didn’t God use a donkey once?